It used to be easy to tell the musical story of Charles
Michael Kittridge Thompson IV - he was Black Francis, leader of the acclaimed
Pixies, then the Pixies broke up, and he was solo artist Frank Black.Even adding ‘& The Catholics’ to
his solo moniker didn't change things.But after The Catholics, the Pixies reunited at Coachella in 2004
(basically starting the ‘alt bands reuniting - and cashing in - trend’), though
only playing the old, much-beloved material.Then Thompson returned to the ‘Black Francis’ name.He also produced the last two Art Brut
(QRO spotlight on), did a score to the
1920 silent film The Golem, teamed up with his wife as Grand
Duchy (QRO album review), and more,
while still putting out solo records - albeit of diminishing returns.But now Frank Black Francis has done
his best off-angle move so far, pairing with longtime friend & tourmate
Reid Paley as Paley & Francis.
While Francis is still best known & loved for his alt-rock
work in Pixies and as Frank Black, recent years have seen him trend into the
alt-country lane, especially since readopting the ‘Black Francis’ name in 2007
with Bluefinger (QRO review).The more stripped-down Francis
certainly had its high points, but by last year's Nonstoperotick (QRO review), they were getting fewer
and farther in between.Teaming up
with the gruffer alt-country troubadour Reid Paley (who's also known for his
winning humor on stage, including opening for Francis) has brought a shot of
vigor into Francis, even as his goes further into even alt-blues & -gospel.
The songs on Paley & Francis (how nice of the more famous of the two not to take
first-billing; though that's not alphabetical order...) go roughly one-two in
terms of who takes the lead, with Paley a much gruffer, saloon-style voice,
even ragtime on pieces such as "On the Corner", "Ugly Life", "The Last Song",
and "Deconstructed", though varying from sad, near-gospel sway ("The Last
Song") to saloon bombast ("Deconstructed").Indeed, Paley's is the more memorable voice on Paley
& Francis, though Francis' guitar work
stands out on such numbers as "Curse", "Crescent Moon", and especially
"Praise", as fine a song in Frank Black Francis' discography as there is.
People looking for new Pixies or Frank Black II won't find it on Paley & Francis, but they should know better by now (Pixies have
been touring behind deluxe edition of Doolittle for over two years now - QRO live review).But the alt-country Black Francis has
been revived with a heavy dose of Reid Paley.